Review Comment:
The authors have addressed my concerns from my previous review:
http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/content/countering-language-attritio...
Comment:
This statement (first paragraph) has been clearly rejected and repeating it, even as citation, probably does the field more harm than good:
Nonetheless, some experts claim that processes such as nation-state consolidation and globalization are producing language attrition so rapidly that up to 90% of all languages alive today will be extinct within a century [7].
See:
http://scholarspace.manoa.hawaii.edu/bitstream/handle/10125/26145/26145....
And a post about these findings at the Long Now Foundation's Rosetta Stone:
http://rosettaproject.org/blog/02013/mar/28/new-estimates-on-rate-of-lan...
Minor:
which has led to emergence of the Web of Data ->
which has led to the emergence of the Web of Data
- 2x:
more fine grained ->
more fine-grained
in an English to German dictionary ->
in an English-to-German dictionary
- maybe break this line so it doesn't run out of the margin:
"abbreviated with plx."
- unclear what is meat here (maybe one-to-some? the relation?):
"Since these models differ from the PanLex one to some extent"
- this footnote is smaller than the others:
15 http://wifo5- 03.informatik.uni- mannheim.de/pubby/
- missing comma between footnote numbers:
SPARQL endpoints16 17
Critical:
- the link returns a 502 Bad Gateway
21 http://panlex.org/teradict/?lg=eng
|